Reply
Contributor
Lasseter
Posts: 18
Registered: 01-31-2012
0

Re: Review system is fouled up


Sun_Cat wrote:

Yeah, that's a pretty effective filtering system they have, that rejects reviews containing "price" and lets that one pass. :smileylol:

 

I reported it, FWIW. It will be interesting to see whether it stays.



In the meantime, a new review has popped up from a reviewer who confesses that he has not read the book, because he just can't get past the name of the main character.  Democracy is in action, though.  These two prank reviews have received nine "not helpful" votes from the good readers of B&N reviews.  And a good thing too, since I'd hate to see Jo Nesbø (the author of the book) or Barnes and Noble lose any business on account of some unfortunate user being swayed by these two rather compelling and wholly negative reviews.

Inspired Wordsmith
keriflur
Posts: 2,199
Registered: 01-05-2010
0

Re: Review system is fouled up


Lasseter wrote:

Sun_Cat wrote:

Yeah, that's a pretty effective filtering system they have, that rejects reviews containing "price" and lets that one pass. :smileylol:

 

I reported it, FWIW. It will be interesting to see whether it stays.



In the meantime, a new review has popped up from a reviewer who confesses that he has not read the book, because he just can't get past the name of the main character.  Democracy is in action, though.  These two prank reviews have received nine "not helpful" votes from the good readers of B&N reviews.  And a good thing too, since I'd hate to see Jo Nesbø (the author of the book) or Barnes and Noble lose any business on account of some unfortunate user being swayed by these two rather compelling and wholly negative reviews.


Ugh, I hate reviews like that.  I mean, yeah, we're all entitled to our opinions, and free speech and all that, but geez, write something useful for the people that are going to read the review later.

 

So, yeah, the system is a mess, but a good part of the problem is that there are a lot of unhelpful people using it.  :smileysad:

I'm on Goodreads - If you friend me send me a PM :smileyhappy:
Currently Reading: The Only Ones
Administrator
BN_AlexG
Posts: 317
Registered: 09-19-2011

Re: Review system is fouled up

Hi all,

 

I'm sorry for all of the trouble everyone has had to this point. Please PM any issues/concerns you have with reviews. I'll do my best to help until our review system is fully transitioned.

 

- Alex

 

Click the Laurel leaf to say thank you for helpful posts. And be sure to come back to click the 'Accept as Solution' button for the post that solved your issue. This may help someone else.
Distinguished Wordsmith
Sun_Cat
Posts: 500
Registered: 12-03-2011

Re: Review system is fouled up


BN_AlexG wrote:

Hi all,

 

I'm sorry for all of the trouble everyone has had to this point. Please PM any issues/concerns you have with reviews. I'll do my best to help until our review system is fully transitioned.

 


Hi, Alex. Thanks for stepping in.

 

Mmm, "fully transitioned" from what to what, exactly? Inquiring minds want to know!

You're invited to visit me on Goodreads.
Currently reading:
Drift by Rachel Maddow
At Home in the Universe by Stuart A. Kauffman
Wordsmith
kamas716
Posts: 275
Registered: 09-28-2011
0

Re: Review system is fouled up

Well, seems at least a part of the Review System has been fixed. It has a new look to it, too.  It no longer posts my reviews as "anonymous" but puts it under my user name.  Still can't edit/delete the review.  And, instead of a header line, it just copies the first sentence (or part of sentence) as the header.

 

Baby steps, right?

www.goodreads.com/kamas716