Reply
Author
Katherine_Howe
Posts: 101
Registered: ‎03-16-2009

history and remorse


PiperMurphy wrote:

Thank you for joining us and taking our questions. I have enjoyed your book very much. It's absolutely fascinating.

 

I have a question about history. One of the most disturbing things about the Salem Trials is that a group of girls could manipulate the situation so successfully. Does history tell us anything about whether any of them eventually felt remorse for their actions or even realized that they contributed to the deaths of innocent people? I have a feeling that even though the trials ended, the belief in the devil didn't end with them.


Hi PiperMurphy,

 

Thank you for the kind words! I am so glad that you are enjoying it.

 

It is eerie to see how much control the young girls were given in the Salem panic - it was very unusual for the time period. Many of the teenage accusers seem to have vanished from history after the Salem episode - Abigail Williams, the accuser made most notorious by Arthur Miller's portrayal of her in The Cruciblewas one of those who has disappeared in the historical record. Another of the girls, however, Ann Putnam, actually made a very public confession in about 1705. At the time Ann was unmarried, and we can surmise that her involvement in the trials might have been part of her relatively marginal status in her society as an adult. She went before her church and publicly apologized for lying, expressing profound sorrow over the lives that she had ruined. One wonders how the victims' families felt while they listened to her.

Author
Katherine_Howe
Posts: 101
Registered: ‎03-16-2009
0 Kudos

on pronouncination


godslioness wrote:

I have a silly question!

 

How do you pronounce Physick?

 

(like psychic or physic)

 

Fab job on your book :smileyhappy:


Hi Godslioness!

 

It's pronounced just like "physic." The K on the end is really just a variant, archaic spelling. Before there were such things as dictionaries, spellings even of everyday words tended to vary dramatically, even when it came to someone's name. For example, an early player in the Salem panic was Lieutenant Ingersoll, whose name appears variously as "Ingersoll," "Ingasoll", "Ingason" and so forth. The variations can give us an interesting sense of how the language sounded, which as you've probably gathered, is something that I found very compelling.

 

KH

Author
Katherine_Howe
Posts: 101
Registered: ‎03-16-2009
0 Kudos

Arlo-ology


eadieburke wrote:

Hi Katherine:

 

My daughter and I are both signed up for this book club. I also read to my husband in the car when we take long drives. We got to around 100 pages during one of our drives and the next day while my husband was at work, I finished the book. I just had to find out what happened next. My husband came home from work that day and said, "Let's go to bed early and you can finish reading to me." Needless to say, I was in big trouble!

 

My husband has since finished to book and we both agreed how much we loved it. His comment was: "It was like a Harry Potter book for adults - hope she has a sequel!"

 

My daughter who has my 18 month old granddaughter has just finished Part 1. She called me last night and said: "I know it must be Chilton that put the circle on the door." I told her to keep reading because I was not giving any spoilers."

 

My husband does have a question: "Is Arlo suppose to be the same dog from the 1600's or is he a descendent from the other dog?"

 

Thanks again for an enjoyable read and we can't wait until your next book!

 

Eadie Burke

 

 


Hi Eadie!

 

I am so glad that you, your husband, and your daughter have been enjoying Physick Book. I like reading to my husband too (though I usually find something very important to share with him just as he's drifting off to sleep.....)

 

As for Arlo, I would actually be curious to open that question up to the board. When does Arlo (or Dog) usually turn up in the story? Does your husband think he's the same dog? What evidence is there in the story in favor or against?

 

KH

Author
Katherine_Howe
Posts: 101
Registered: ‎03-16-2009

Tomatogate!


biljounc63 wrote:

HI Katherine,

I am enjoying your book and am glad to be part of this program.

 

I am reading the book according the the club schedule so my question may be answered later in the book. I know that this book is a work of fiction. I am from the western part of the MA. Many of us are having an issue with the state or Granna's garden having vegetables (tomatoes etc.) ready for harvest in a garden that had been abandoned for 20 years in early June on MA. This is so far from being plausible that I shook my head as I read it. It was just too perfect to have dinner just waiting to be harvested on the first night at the house Was this done on purpose or was it part of your plan for the mysterious house that time seems to have forgotten?   


Hi biljounc63!

 

I am glad that you are enjoying the book so far, and hope that you continue to enjoy it as it unfolds into Part II.

 

It seems like the question of the garden at the Milk Street house has been the subject of some controversy. Here are a couple of thoughts.

 

Whenever I am reading a novel, I try to pay close attention to how the author manipulates details. Usually if something really jumps out at me in a novel, some sort of startling or telling detail, I will pay closer attention to it on the grounds that it might have something important to tell me. Maybe it is meant to elucidate a particular aspect of a character's personality, or maybe it's supposed to clue me into a coming turn in the plot. It's true that there are a lot of things "wrong" at Granna's house. It's also true that the kinds of things that are off kilter there are not necessarily the kinds of things that two bookish, dorm-dwelling city girls would immediately notice. Or perhaps they would sense that something was sort of off, but they wouldn't be able to put their fingers on it exactly.

 

If we assume that the "offness" of the Milk Street house is supposed to stand out to a reader, if not quite to Connie and Liz, then what do you think those wrong-seeming details are trying to say?

 

KH

Frequent Contributor
mooks
Posts: 27
Registered: ‎03-24-2009
0 Kudos

Re: Questions for Katherine Howe?

Hi Ms. Howe,

 

First, I wanted to thank you for writing this wonderful novel and partnering with Barnes & Noble to host the First Look Book Club.  This is my first time to do this and I love it!  Not just the generous gift of the book but also the time and energy that you and B&N put into these discussions.

 

Could you tell us more about your inspiration for the character of Deliverance Dane and her daughter Mercy?  How did you come up with the details of her life?    It's amazing that you begun this while preparing for your own orals and dissertation.

 

Congratulations on such a fascinating and unusual book!

 

Mooks

Author
Katherine_Howe
Posts: 101
Registered: ‎03-16-2009
0 Kudos

Re: Questions for Katherine Howe?


Bonnie824 wrote:
I have a non writing/book question. You had Connie attend Mount Holyoke for undergraduate school and I wondered why. Did you attend MH? I ask because my youngest daughter is there now, and I already had planned to pass this book to her when she comes home for the summer in May.

Hi Bonnie824!

 

I did not attend Mount Holyoke - I went to Columbia. But Mount Holyoke just seemed like a good fit for Connie. I'm not sure why. Do you think it is a good fit for her, the way it is a good fit for your daughter?

 

KH

Author
Katherine_Howe
Posts: 101
Registered: ‎03-16-2009

Connie vs. Katherine, a question of doppelgangers


Adeline79 wrote:

Hi Katherine,

 

Congratulations on the publication of your first novel!

 

I am wondering, To what extent did you use yourself in forming the character Connie? Obviously you are both grad students who have someone from the Salem witch trials in your family history. Are there any other similarities?

 

 


Thanks, Adeline79! It's been very exciting so far.

 

I think Connie and I have certain traits in common, for sure, but we are also very different. For one thing, Connie is ten years older than I am, so a lot of our pop cultural frameworks are different. If you visit her on Facebook, you'll see that she is a killer Lexulous player - much better than I am. She is also a better student - she had a very linear acadmic path, while I (ahem) wrote a 400-odd page novel, all in the interest of procrastination. We do not particularly look alike, we dress very differently, and we had completely opposite upbringings. Also, Connie bites her nails, which I would never do.

 

However, Connie shares my basic bookishness. Like me, she can be kind of blunt. We both have dogs of mysterious antecendent. And we both wander around in the present, imagining the past around us as we go. So perhaps we're not that different after all.

 

KH

Frequent Contributor
mooks
Posts: 27
Registered: ‎03-24-2009
0 Kudos

Re: Hello hello!

Hi Ms Howe,

 

I enjoyed the book very much and was wondering about the ARC process.  At the point that the book is distributed to book clubs as an ARC, is it largely completed?  Would any final changes be limited to typos or is it possible that you and publisher could add large chunks that would further develop the characters of Deliverance and Mercy and tell us more about their lives?

 

I do intend to recommend the book to friends, but it didn't feel complete when I'd finished it.  You know the feeling of putting down a wonderful book and being able to just savor the ending?  I'd expected that with this book but instead had been restless for more.   Is there any chance that additional chapters might be woven in?

 

Thanks!
Mooks

Author
Katherine_Howe
Posts: 101
Registered: ‎03-16-2009

On history and writing


DebsScott wrote:

Hello and welcome Ms. Howe!  First please allow me to compliment you on your novel.  It is great reading...you've done a wonderful job pulling me into the story with your seamless time shifts, fantastic descriptions of very believable characters and real history.  Brilliant!

 

My question is this:  As I read your book, it seems like it was so effortless for you to include real history in your story.  I have done some writing myself and have found, at times, the research that goes into a story can be tedious but an absolute must to insure accuracy.  Did you ever encounter this problem while writing and what was the best way to overcome it?   Was it easier for you to jot down thoughts and notes as they occurred to you then research as needed?  Or did you gather all your research first (history, herbs and their uses etc.) then entwine it into the story? (Oops...okay, that was more than one question.)

 

Thank you for allowing us to read your book and discuss it in this manner; it is incredibly courageous of you! :smileywink:   

Message Edited by DebsScott on 04-05-2009 11:58 PM

Hi DebsScott!

 

Thank you so much for these kind words. It's been a real pleasure watching people's responses as the book unfolds.

 

This is a difficult question to answer. I've learned that I work in layers. I'll be drawn to a given question or milieu (the time period, the most basic elements of the plot). I'll begin reading and research, which in this case meant getting a thorough grounding in the secondary source literature. I spent so much time reading before I knew for sure that it would work as a novel that I used the materials to teach a research seminar for freshmen at BU, because I find that the surest way to learn something well is to have to teach it to someone else. Then I let everything simmer. The simmering goes on for awhile.

 

Finally, I mapped out an outline for the whole book, including specific characters, locations, time periods, and so forth. My first plan for the book was to illustrate the historical portion of the story not in a narrative fashion, but through made-up primary sources (you see the residue of this technique in Deliverance's probate record, and in some of Prudence's journal entries). Then we would read exactly what Connie reads, when she reads it. But after awhile that seemed too dry or academic an approach, so I set it aside.

 

All of which is a very long way of saying that I wrote the entire book in order as you see it, but that the actual writing took place after about a year and a half of research and lots and lots of simmering. A few details and tweaks were added along the way of course, twists discarded, characters who I thought would be important wound not up being in the story at all, and a few showed up without my consciously inviting them. But each snippet from the past relates directly to the action in the present, and so I had to write them all in order, or the thread might have gotten lost.

 

I hope that you enjoy the rest of the book! Thank you so much for reading.

 

KH

Correspondent
m3girl
Posts: 194
Registered: ‎03-02-2007
0 Kudos

Re: Questions for Katherine Howe?

Welcome to First Look, Ms Howe and thank you for participating.  I have to say that I am enjoying your novel quite a bit - it's one of those where I look forward to about 9pm in the evening when I know I can sit down and read a few chapters.  The discussions have been well attended - so I'm guessing that I am not alone in my opinion.

I have a couple of questions...

How long did it take you to write the book?  How many drafts did you write?  How much effort did you need to do with revisions?

How much time did you spend researching?

Where did you get the idea of the 'visions'?

I love the voice of the narrator - very smooth and easy.  I also like the length of the chapters and that there are breaks in between.  Sort of a mechanical thing - but life is busy and I like reading books that are easy to pick up and then put down when needed - and still be able to pick things up where they left off.

I believe I will be recommending this to all of my 'reading' friends.

Susan 

Author
Katherine_Howe
Posts: 101
Registered: ‎03-16-2009
0 Kudos

Re: Questions for Katherine Howe?


 Personal link - Elizabeth Proctor and Elizabeth Howe

 

I'm not that familiar with the people directly involved in the Salem witch trials and am very curious as to how your family's link to Elizabeth Proctor and Elizabeth Howe directly affected your own childhood and life.  Did you grow up in the New England area or did you move there during your college and graduate school years?  Are there family stories that you'd be willing to share with the group?

 

Inspiration for the novel

Are you fond of fantasy novels and magic? How did you get the idea for your story? How did you come up with characters of Deliverance and Mercy?

 

Is there a particular house that inspired the description of Sophia's cottage in Marblehead?  The image of the house, its furnishings and the type of life that they had to live there was fascinating.




Hello hello!

 

Thank you so much for reading. I hope that you have been finding things in the book to enjoy.

 

1. I did not grow up in New England, but I sometimes say that I grew up facing East. I moved to the east coast at 18, and felt immediately at home. As a child I felt like my grandmother's house was a little isloated island of Yankiness - dark wood, odd nautical knick knacks, shelves and shelves of books, needlepoint. And it was always sixty degrees in her house, even though we were in a warm part of the country. Of course now I know that sixty degrees is the perfect temperature for a house!

 

The witch connection was uncovered by my aunt when I was a teenager. I reacted as a teenager would - "AWESOME!" I said. Then I started practicing my cackle. I didn't give it much more thought than that until I was an adult, when I began to study the history of American culture in earnest. I was struck by the extent to which we begin to lose a sense that the people in the past were actual individuals, living everyday lives. For instance, one summer afternoon I was cooking in our Marblehead apartment for a large group of family and friends. It was suffocatingly hot, and I was sweating by the stove (no A/C, of course). I found myself thinking about how many women in my past would have experienced this exact sensation - something in the oven, a hot summer day, hungry family, pouring down sweat in the kitchen. I thought that this was the kind of experience, or sensation, that is lost in the study of history, the little everyday details of life. That realization, more than anything, led me to want to write this story.

 

2. Deliverance Dane was a real person, who was accused near the end of the Salem panic. I latched onto her for two reasons: first, I found her name to be incredibly evocative, and second, we know very little about her, and so I had room to imagine around her. Check out the historical note at the end of the book for more on what in the book is based in fact.

 

3. Yes. But it's a secret. 

 

KH

Inspired Wordsmith
eadieburke
Posts: 1,921
Registered: ‎01-27-2007

Re: Arlo-ology

[ Edited ]

                                ***SPOILER***

 


Katherine_Howe wrote:

eadieburke wrote:

Hi Katherine:

 

My daughter and I are both signed up for this book club. I also read to my husband in the car when we take long drives. We got to around 100 pages during one of our drives and the next day while my husband was at work, I finished the book. I just had to find out what happened next. My husband came home from work that day and said, "Let's go to bed early and you can finish reading to me." Needless to say, I was in big trouble!

 

My husband has since finished to book and we both agreed how much we loved it. His comment was: "It was like a Harry Potter book for adults - hope she has a sequel!"

 

My daughter who has my 18 month old granddaughter has just finished Part 1. She called me last night and said: "I know it must be Chilton that put the circle on the door." I told her to keep reading because I was not giving any spoilers."

 

My husband does have a question: "Is Arlo suppose to be the same dog from the 1600's or is he a descendent from the other dog?"

 

Thanks again for an enjoyable read and we can't wait until your next book!

 

Eadie Burke

 

 


Hi Eadie!

 

I am so glad that you, your husband, and your daughter have been enjoying Physick Book. I like reading to my husband too (though I usually find something very important to share with him just as he's drifting off to sleep.....)

 

As for Arlo, I would actually be curious to open that question up to the board. When does Arlo (or Dog) usually turn up in the story? Does your husband think he's the same dog? What evidence is there in the story in favor or against?

 

KH


I just checked with my husband and he thinks it is the same dog or some type of spirit of the dog from the 1600's.

 

The descriptions of all the dogs in the 1600's and 1991 seem very similiar and the dog just seems to appear and disappear at times.

 

Jonas in the prologue remarks that he did not notice the dog at first. Arlo seems to find Connie while coming out of a bush. When Liz and Connie arrive at the Milk St. house, Arlo seems to disappear into the shadows and finds the gate. Mercy just happens upon Dog while in her garden picking peas. While Connie and Sam are swimming, Arlo is guarding her towel and then Arlo seems to fade to the pale moonlit color of the fog. Arlo seems to be Connie's protector too. He is in the house while Sam is there and also helps Connie fight off Chilton. Dog was also with Mercy at the time of Deliverance's hanging. Then at the end of the book, a dog is seen sleeping next to a headstone with a faint letter D as the first letter of the name and suddenly the dog disappeared.

 

Too many coincidences of the dog appearing and disappearing at different times. Seems like a ghost to me.

 

Message Edited by rkubie on 04-06-2009 10:47 PM
Message Edited by rkubie on 04-06-2009 11:29 PM
Eadie - A day out-of-doors, someone I loved to talk with, a good book and some simple food and music -- that would be rest. - Eleanor Roosevelt
New User
schoolofmark
Posts: 3
Registered: ‎03-24-2009
0 Kudos

Re: Questions for Katherine Howe?

This may be posted elsewhere, but what is the significance of having the "modern" time set in 1991?
Author
Katherine_Howe
Posts: 101
Registered: ‎03-16-2009
0 Kudos

drafts and revisions


m3girl wrote:

Welcome to First Look, Ms Howe and thank you for participating.  I have to say that I am enjoying your novel quite a bit - it's one of those where I look forward to about 9pm in the evening when I know I can sit down and read a few chapters.  The discussions have been well attended - so I'm guessing that I am not alone in my opinion.

I have a couple of questions...

How long did it take you to write the book?  How many drafts did you write?  How much effort did you need to do with revisions?

How much time did you spend researching?

Where did you get the idea of the 'visions'?

I love the voice of the narrator - very smooth and easy.  I also like the length of the chapters and that there are breaks in between.  Sort of a mechanical thing - but life is busy and I like reading books that are easy to pick up and then put down when needed - and still be able to pick things up where they left off.

I believe I will be recommending this to all of my 'reading' friends.

Susan 


Hi M3girl,

 

I am so glad that you are enjoying it, and thank you for recommending it to your friends. As I told a group yesterday, books make great gifts! 

 

From first glimmerings of an idea, which started in fall of 2005, to the first completed draft manuscript, which was Labor Day 2007, it was about two years. Then another year of tweaks and revision. I went through six full drafts of the whole manuscript - maybe seven? Some parts took more work than others. The interlude in which Mercy is a little girl appears almost verbatim the way it first appeared on my laptop. Chapter 1, however, the oral exam chapter, took so many revisions it was just ridiculous. Twelve, at least! I can safely say that I never want to read that chapter again.

 

As for the visions, I would say that most of the unusual events in the book follow the same basic structure - they are a lot like what happens in "real" life, but sort of raised up a level. I wondered what a daydream would look like if it were more vivid, more tangible, and had something specific to say.

 

KH

Author
Katherine_Howe
Posts: 101
Registered: ‎03-16-2009
0 Kudos

why 1991?


schoolofmark wrote:
This may be posted elsewhere, but what is the significance of having the "modern" time set in 1991?

Hi Schoolofmark,

 

Connie belongs in 1991 because while it feels like the present, it is actually the past. What do you think Connie's life would look like if she were living in 2009? How would the story have unfolded differently, do you think?

 

KH

Frequent Contributor
hookedonbooks09
Posts: 128
Registered: ‎02-04-2009
0 Kudos

Re: Questions for Katherine Howe?

Hi Katherine!  Welcome and thank you for writing your book!  :-)

 

I have two questions:  The first is, how much of Arlo did you take from your own dog, if anything?

 

The second question is:  Before or after writing this book, did you also investigate to any degree the history of your relatives from Salem?

 

Again, thanks for writing this book and for allowing us to share it before it's true "birth".  I guess you're getting the message about that sequel---better get writing!

Outside of a dog, a book is man's best friend. Inside of a dog it's too dark to read. ~Groucho Marx
Author
Katherine_Howe
Posts: 101
Registered: ‎03-16-2009
0 Kudos

Re: Questions for Katherine Howe?


candeny6 wrote:
Hi Katherine!  It has been such a privilege to read this book before it is released.  It has been so much better than I could have ever imagined.  I've been recommending it to everyone I know!  You did a great job!

Thank you so much, Candi! I am delighted that you have been enjoying it so much.

If you're on Facebook, you should join my fan page. I'll be announcing all novel related news there first, including reading and signing dates. Here's a link:

 

http://www.facebook.com/home.php?#/pages/Katherine-Howe/47456997235?ref=ts
Author
Katherine_Howe
Posts: 101
Registered: ‎03-16-2009

Re: Hello hello!


mooks wrote:

Hi Ms Howe,

 

I enjoyed the book very much and was wondering about the ARC process.  At the point that the book is distributed to book clubs as an ARC, is it largely completed?  Would any final changes be limited to typos or is it possible that you and publisher could add large chunks that would further develop the characters of Deliverance and Mercy and tell us more about their lives?

 

I do intend to recommend the book to friends, but it didn't feel complete when I'd finished it.  You know the feeling of putting down a wonderful book and being able to just savor the ending?  I'd expected that with this book but instead had been restless for more.   Is there any chance that additional chapters might be woven in?

 

Thanks!
Mooks


Hi Mooks,

 

The ARC is a fairly accurate picture of what the final book will look like, barring a few editorial corrections here and there. Part of the reason that the women in the past in Physick Book have such a fragmented story is that it mirrors our understanding of history - every so often we can find these very vivid representations of a moment in someone's life, but so much of the rest of their story will be lost to time. 

 

However, I will admit to harboring secret plans for a sequel. I agree that there is definitely more to say in this story, and I am glad that you feel that way too.

 

Thank you for reading!

 

KH

Inspired Correspondent
Adeline79
Posts: 63
Registered: ‎03-17-2009
0 Kudos

Re: Questions for Katherine Howe?

Hi Katherine,

 

How easy was it for you to find a publisher considering that it was your first book? Did you end up finishing your studies?

 

I signed up as a fan on facebook and hope that I can catch you at a book signing and get my advance reader copy signed! 

http://thereadingjourney.blogspot.com
Inspired Correspondent
bookloverjb85
Posts: 168
Registered: ‎10-12-2007
0 Kudos

Re: Questions for Katherine Howe?

Thank you for joining us Katherine!!  I have to say that I have only read Chapters 1-6 and part of 7 (and still reading), but I love the book so far.  I get so into the plot line and the characters that it's hard to distract me.

 

I am not sure if anyone else has asked these questions, but did you have to spend a lot of time researching the history of the Salem witch trials?  If so, about how much time do you think you spent on it?

 

Where did you come up with the idea for the story?  Did it just come to you one day or did someone give you the idea?

 

 

--Jen--

"A house without books is like a room without windows."--Horace Mann