20 Questions

[Psychee]

9.  If it exists but is not there, is it somewhere else?

10.  Is it magical?

11.  Is it tangible?

12.  Is it a concept, like "The Trace"?

13.  Is it associated with  the Ministry?

14.  Is it the King's Cross Station in Harry's mind when he is between life and death?

[Jules934]

I'm thinking of a thing that's really not there.

1-7.   It is only mentioned in book 7.

   8.   No, it does not exist in the mind of a Lovegood. 

         I'm afraid my hint is leading you astray.  It really exists.  Don't make too much of it.  Perhaps it will be amusing when the answer is revealed

   9.  No, it is as there as it can be. (The Q was  If it exists but is not there, is it somewhere else?)

10.  No, it is not magical, as least according to my definition of magic, but you might argue with me.

11.  No, it is not tangible.

12.  No, it is not a concept, like "The Trace".

13.  No, it is not associated with  the Ministry.

14.  No, it is not the King's Cross Station in Harry's mind when he is between life and death?

[Psychee]

15.  Can it be seen?

16.  Is it a ghostly something, like, for instance, the Bloody Baron's chains?

17.  Is it in the King's Cross chapter of the book?

18.  Can it be seen?

19.  Is the Nothingness (the place where magical stuff disappears to- the answer that McGonagall gave to the Ravenclaw riddle)?

[Jules934]

I'm thinking of a thing that's really not there.

1-7.   It is only mentioned in book 7.

   8.   No, it does not exist in the mind of a Lovegood. 

         I'm afraid my hint is leading you astray.  It really exists.  Don't make too much of it.  Perhaps it will be amusing when the answer is revealed

   9.  No, it is as there as it can be. (The Q was  If it exists but is not there, is it somewhere else?)

10.  No, it is not magical, as least according to my definition of magic, but you might argue with me.

11.  No, it is not tangible.

12.  No, it is not a concept, like "The Trace".

13.  No, it is not associated with  the Ministry.

14.  No, it is not the King's Cross Station in Harry's mind when he is between life and death.

15.  Yes, it can be seen.  Or at least, that it exists can be seen.

16.  No, it is not a ghostly something, like, for instance, the Bloody Baron's chains.

17.  No, it is not in the King's Cross chapter of the book.

18.  Yes, it can be seen.  Or at least, that it exists can be seen.

19.  No, it is not the Nothingness (the place where magical stuff disappears to- the answer that McGonagall gave to the Ravenclaw riddle).

Marvelous answers!  But what I am thinking of is just one unique example in a class of everyday things in both universi.

[Psychee]

20.  Is it associated with the Room of Requirment?

21.  Is it at Hogwarts?

22.  Is it something that moved around with H,H, and R?

[Jules934]

I'm thinking of a thing that's really not there.

1-7.   It is only mentioned in book 7.

   8.   No, it does not exist in the mind of a Lovegood. 

         I'm afraid my hint is leading you astray.  It really exists.  Don't make too much of it.  Perhaps it will be amusing when the answer is revealed

   9.  No, it is as there as it can be. (The Q was  If it exists but is not there, is it somewhere else?)

10.  No, it is not magical, as least according to my definition of magic, but you might argue with me.

11.  No, it is not tangible.

12.  No, it is not a concept, like "The Trace".

13.  No, it is not associated with  the Ministry.

14.  No, it is not the King's Cross Station in Harry's mind when he is between life and death.

15.  Yes, it can be seen.  Or at least, that it exists can be seen.

16.  No, it is not a ghostly something, like, for instance, the Bloody Baron's chains.

17.  No, it is not in the King's Cross chapter of the book.

18.  Yes, it can be seen.  Or at least, that it exists can be seen.

19.  No, it is not the Nothingness (the place where magical stuff disappears to- the answer that McGonagall gave to the Ravenclaw riddle).

Marvelous answers!  But what I am thinking of is just one unique example in a class of everyday things in both universi.

20.  No, it is not associated with the Room of Requirment.

21.  Yes, it is at Hogwarts.

22.  No, it is not something that moved around with H,H, and R.

[Kat-NE]

23. Do we see it in the Room of Requirement?

24. Do we see it during the battle(s) at Hogwarts?

[Jules934]

I'm thinking of a thing that's really not there.

1-7.   It is only mentioned in book 7.

   8.   No, it does not exist in the mind of a Lovegood. 

         I'm afraid my hint is leading you astray.  It really exists.  Don't make too much of it.  Perhaps it will be amusing when the answer is revealed

   9.  No, it is as there as it can be. (The Q was  If it exists but is not there, is it somewhere else?)

10.  No, it is not magical, as least according to my definition of magic, but you might argue with me.

11.  No, it is not tangible.

12.  No, it is not a concept, like "The Trace".

13.  No, it is not associated with  the Ministry.

14.  No, it is not the King's Cross Station in Harry's mind when he is between life and death.

15.  Yes, it can be seen.  Or at least, that it exists can be seen.

16.  No, it is not a ghostly something, like, for instance, the Bloody Baron's chains.

17.  No, it is not in the King's Cross chapter of the book.

18.  Yes, it can be seen.  Or at least, that it exists can be seen.

19.  No, it is not the Nothingness (the place where magical stuff disappears to- the answer that McGonagall gave to the Ravenclaw riddle).

Marvelous answers!  But what I am thinking of is just one unique example in a class of everyday things in both universi.

20.  No, it is not associated with the Room of Requirment.

21.  Yes, it is at Hogwarts.

22.  No, it is not something that moved around with H,H, and R.

23.  No, we do not see it in the Room of Requirement.

24.  Yes, we see it during the battle(s) at Hogwarts.

[Psychee]

25.  Is it a kind of protection, like Nagini's bubble?

[Jules934]

I'm thinking of a thing that's really not there.

1-7.   It is only mentioned in book 7.

   8.   No, it does not exist in the mind of a Lovegood. 

         I'm afraid my hint is leading you astray.  It really exists.  Don't make too much of it.  Perhaps it will be amusing when the answer is revealed

   9.  No, it is as there as it can be. (The Q was  If it exists but is not there, is it somewhere else?)

10.  No, it is not magical, as least according to my definition of magic, but you might argue with me.

11.  No, it is not tangible.

12.  No, it is not a concept, like "The Trace".

13.  No, it is not associated with  the Ministry.

14.  No, it is not the King's Cross Station in Harry's mind when he is between life and death.

15.  Yes, it can be seen.  Or at least, that it exists can be seen.

16.  No, it is not a ghostly something, like, for instance, the Bloody Baron's chains.

17.  No, it is not in the King's Cross chapter of the book.

18.  Yes, it can be seen.  Or at least, that it exists can be seen.

19.  No, it is not the Nothingness (the place where magical stuff disappears to- the answer that McGonagall gave to the Ravenclaw riddle).

Marvelous answers!  But what I am thinking of is just one unique example in a class of everyday things in both universi.

20.  No, it is not associated with the Room of Requirment.

21.  Yes, it is at Hogwarts.

22.  No, it is not something that moved around with H,H, and R.

23.  No, we do not see it in the Room of Requirement.

24.  Yes, we see it during the battle(s) at Hogwarts.

25.  No, it is not a kind of protection, like Nagini's bubble.

[Psychee]

26.  Is it associated with Voldemort?

27.  Is it created by magic?

28.  Did we see it in the first battle of Hogwarts? (before Harry "died").

[Jules934]

I'm thinking of a thing that's really not there.

1-7.   It is only mentioned in book 7.

   8.   No, it does not exist in the mind of a Lovegood. 

         I'm afraid my hint is leading you astray.  It really exists.  Don't make too much of it.  Perhaps it will be amusing when the answer is revealed

   9.  No, it is as there as it can be. (The Q was  If it exists but is not there, is it somewhere else?)

10.  No, it is not magical, as least according to my definition of magic, but you might argue with me.

11.  No, it is not tangible.

12.  No, it is not a concept, like "The Trace".

13.  No, it is not associated with  the Ministry.

14.  No, it is not the King's Cross Station in Harry's mind when he is between life and death.

15.  Yes, it can be seen.  Or at least, that it exists can be seen.

16.  No, it is not a ghostly something, like, for instance, the Bloody Baron's chains.

17.  No, it is not in the King's Cross chapter of the book.

18.  Yes, it can be seen.  Or at least, that it exists can be seen.

19.  No, it is not the Nothingness (the place where magical stuff disappears to- the answer that McGonagall gave to the Ravenclaw riddle).

Marvelous answers!  But what I am thinking of is just one unique example in a class of everyday things in both universi.

20.  No, it is not associated with the Room of Requirment.

21.  Yes, it is at Hogwarts.

22.  No, it is not something that moved around with H,H, and R.

23.  No, we do not see it in the Room of Requirement.

24.  Yes, we see it during the battle(s) at Hogwarts.

25.  No, it is not a kind of protection, like Nagini's bubble.

26.  No, it is not associated with Voldemort.  At lease only in a verry, verry distant, distant way, so don't even think about it.

27.  JKR never said whether was created by magic or was just circumstantial.

28.  No, we did not see it in the first battle of Hogwarts? (before Harry "died").

[Jules934]

I'm thinking of a thing that's really not there.

1-7.   It is only mentioned in book 7.

   8.   No, it does not exist in the mind of a Lovegood. 

         I'm afraid my hint is leading you astray.  It really exists.  Don't make too much of it.  Perhaps it will be amusing when the answer is revealed

   9.  No, it is as there as it can be. (The Q was  If it exists but is not there, is it somewhere else?)

10.  No, it is not magical, as least according to my definition of magic, but you might argue with me.

11.  No, it is not tangible.

12.  No, it is not a concept, like "The Trace".

13.  No, it is not associated with  the Ministry.

14.  No, it is not the King's Cross Station in Harry's mind when he is between life and death.

15.  Yes, it can be seen.  Or at least, that it exists can be seen.

16.  No, it is not a ghostly something, like, for instance, the Bloody Baron's chains.

17.  No, it is not in the King's Cross chapter of the book.

18.  Yes, it can be seen.  Or at least, that it exists can be seen.

19.  No, it is not the Nothingness (the place where magical stuff disappears to- the answer that McGonagall gave to the Ravenclaw riddle).

Marvelous answers!  But what I am thinking of is just one unique example in a class of everyday things in both universi.

20.  No, it is not associated with the Room of Requirment.

21.  Yes, it is at Hogwarts.

22.  No, it is not something that moved around with H,H, and R.

23.  No, we do not see it in the Room of Requirement.

24.  Yes, we see it during the battle(s) at Hogwarts.

25.  No, it is not a kind of protection, like Nagini's bubble.

26.  No, it is not associated with Voldemort.  At lease only in a verry, verry distant, distant way, so don't even think about it.

27.  JKR never said whether was created by magic or was just circumstantial.

28.  CORRECTION   YES  we DO see it in the first battle of Hogwarts. (before Harry "died"). CRRECTION

[Kreacherteacher]

29. Does it have anything to do with Snape?

30. Does it have anything to do with Ravenclaw?

[Jules934]

I'm thinking of a thing that's really not there.

1-7.   It is only mentioned in book 7.

   8.   No, it does not exist in the mind of a Lovegood. 

         I'm afraid my hint is leading you astray.  It really exists.  Don't make too much of it.  Perhaps it will be amusing when the answer is revealed

   9.  No, it is as there as it can be. (The Q was  If it exists but is not there, is it somewhere else?)

10.  No, it is not magical, as least according to my definition of magic, but you might argue with me.

11.  No, it is not tangible.

12.  No, it is not a concept, like "The Trace".

13.  No, it is not associated with  the Ministry.

14.  No, it is not the King's Cross Station in Harry's mind when he is between life and death.

15.  Yes, it can be seen.  Or at least, that it exists can be seen.

16.  No, it is not a ghostly something, like, for instance, the Bloody Baron's chains.

17.  No, it is not in the King's Cross chapter of the book.

18.  Yes, it can be seen.  Or at least, that it exists can be seen.

19.  No, it is not the Nothingness (the place where magical stuff disappears to- the answer that McGonagall gave to the Ravenclaw riddle).

Marvelous answers!  But what I am thinking of is just one unique example in a class of everyday things in both universi.

20.  No, it is not associated with the Room of Requirment.

21.  Yes, it is at Hogwarts.

22.  No, it is not something that moved around with H,H, and R.

23.  No, we do not see it in the Room of Requirement.

24.  Yes, we see it during the battle(s) at Hogwarts.

25.  No, it is not a kind of protection, like Nagini's bubble.

26.  No, it is not associated with Voldemort.  At lease only in a verry, verry distant, distant way, so don't even think about it.

27.  JKR never said whether was created by magic or was just circumstantial.

28.  CORRECTION   YES  we DO see it in the first battle of Hogwarts. (before Harry "died"). CRRECTION

29. Yes, it has something to do with Snape.

30. No, it does not have anything to do with Ravenclaw. 

[Kreacherteacher]

31. Is it Snape's memories?

[Jules934]

I'm thinking of a thing that's really not there.

1-7.   It is only mentioned in book 7.

   8.   No, it does not exist in the mind of a Lovegood. 

         I'm afraid my hint is leading you astray.  It really exists.  Don't make too much of it.  Perhaps it will be amusing when the answer is revealed

   9.  No, it is as there as it can be. (The Q was  If it exists but is not there, is it somewhere else?)

10.  No, it is not magical, as least according to my definition of magic, but you might argue with me.

11.  No, it is not tangible.

12.  No, it is not a concept, like "The Trace".

13.  No, it is not associated with  the Ministry.

14.  No, it is not the King's Cross Station in Harry's mind when he is between life and death.

15.  Yes, it can be seen.  Or at least, that it exists can be seen.

16.  No, it is not a ghostly something, like, for instance, the Bloody Baron's chains.

17.  No, it is not in the King's Cross chapter of the book.

18.  Yes, it can be seen.  Or at least, that it exists can be seen.

19.  No, it is not the Nothingness (the place where magical stuff disappears to- the answer that McGonagall gave to the Ravenclaw riddle).

Marvelous answers!  But what I am thinking of is just one unique example in a class of everyday things in both universi.

20.  No, it is not associated with the Room of Requirment.

21.  Yes, it is at Hogwarts.

22.  No, it is not something that moved around with H,H, and R.

23.  No, we do not see it in the Room of Requirement.

24.  Yes, we see it during the battle(s) at Hogwarts.

25.  No, it is not a kind of protection, like Nagini's bubble.

26.  No, it is not associated with Voldemort.  At lease only in a verry, verry distant, distant way, so don't even think about it.

27.  JKR never said whether was created by magic or was just circumstantial.

28.  CORRECTION   YES  we DO see it in the first battle of Hogwarts. (before Harry "died"). CRRECTION

29. Yes, it has something to do with Snape.

30. No, it does not have anything to do with Ravenclaw.

31. No, it is not Snape's memories.

[Kat-NE]

32. Is it mentioned/seen in Snape's memories?

[Jules934]

I'm thinking of a thing that's really not there.

1-7.   It is only mentioned in book 7.

   8.   No, it does not exist in the mind of a Lovegood. 

         I'm afraid my hint is leading you astray.  It really exists.  Don't make too much of it.  Perhaps it will be amusing when the answer is revealed

   9.  No, it is as there as it can be. (The Q was  If it exists but is not there, is it somewhere else?)

10.  No, it is not magical, as least according to my definition of magic, but you might argue with me.

11.  No, it is not tangible.

12.  No, it is not a concept, like "The Trace".

13.  No, it is not associated with  the Ministry.

14.  No, it is not the King's Cross Station in Harry's mind when he is between life and death.

15.  Yes, it can be seen.  Or at least, that it exists can be seen.

16.  No, it is not a ghostly something, like, for instance, the Bloody Baron's chains.

17.  No, it is not in the King's Cross chapter of the book.

18.  Yes, it can be seen.  Or at least, that it exists can be seen.

19.  No, it is not the Nothingness (the place where magical stuff disappears to- the answer that McGonagall gave to the Ravenclaw riddle).

Marvelous answers!  But what I am thinking of is just one unique example in a class of everyday things in both universi.

20.  No, it is not associated with the Room of Requirment.

21.  Yes, it is at Hogwarts.

22.  No, it is not something that moved around with H,H, and R.

23.  No, we do not see it in the Room of Requirement.

24.  Yes, we see it during the battle(s) at Hogwarts.

25.  No, it is not a kind of protection, like Nagini's bubble.

26.  No, it is not associated with Voldemort.  At lease only in a verry, verry distant, distant way, so don't even think about it.

27.  JKR never said whether was created by magic or was just circumstantial.

28.  CORRECTION   YES  we DO see it in the first battle of Hogwarts. (before Harry "died"). CRRECTION

29. Yes, it has something to do with Snape.

30. No, it does not have anything to do with Ravenclaw.

31. No, it is not Snape's memories.

32. No, it is not  mentioned/seen in Snape's memories.

[Kat-NE]

33. Do we see anyone in the Trio use it?

34. Do we see Snape use it?

Perhaps a hint would help?!!!