- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Mark as New
- Mark as Read
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Email to a Friend
- Printer Friendly Page
- Report Abuse to a Moderator
I am a purveyor of intimacy, a hawker of happily ever after. So the only heartache I dig in genre fiction is the short-lived, angsty kind that crops up in romance long after "boy meets girl," somewhere between "boy loses girl" and "boy drops to his knees begging for girl's forgiveness, after which girl raises him up to become the equal partner in love boy was destined to be."
Or something like that.
It's true that most folks
don't understand how closely romance fiction has to follow real-life relational
intricacies for readers to buy into a novel's premise. Yet romance clearly is not in toto about
relational authenticity, that life-long journey through little hurts, small
joys, big desires and, often, really sucky interactions with folks we choose to
love and commit to for the long haul.
Long haul, of course, being subjective, since so many real-life love matches
never make it through the short lug. So
who'd want to dwell on that in their escapist leisure time? Not me, for sure...except for recently when I
picked up an off-beat and enticing little tome by Kathleen Horan called
"Relationship Obits : The Final Resting Place for Love Gone Wrong."
"Relationship Obits" is a compilation of selected entries from Horan's Website,
RelationshipObit.com. She started the
site after the demise of a three-year love connection - and the untimely death
of her father just two weeks later.
While writing her father's obituary, the WNYC and internationally aired radio
journalist wondered whether writing the story of the "life and death" of one's
romantic relationship might be as cathartic and closure inducing. Soon after, RelationshipObit.com was born and
took off, offering a cyberspot for folks to work out digitally
the stages of their love affairs and grief in ways humorous, touching,
bittersweet and sometimes just a smidge
bitter.
And mostly entertaining, because these folks seem to want to share in fairly
creative submissions some of the absurdities they couldn't see and maybe
couldn't let go of until they laid them all out - and to rest - in their online
obits.
I won't lie; when I saw the publisher touting this book as " a voyeuristic romp through the unexplored underbelly of love and life," I expected another craptastic exploitation of other folks' misfortune ‘cause, gee, online and off, that just never gets old. Yet I stood corrected when I learned from Horan's introduction the reasons behind her developing her site - and the empathy with which Horan approaches the project.
Why isn't "Obits" a wonking-great, misery lovers'
train wreck? First, Horan's got creds and chops; it doesn't seem her style. More important, the folks who experience the
pain control the information. So the
entertainment isn't at their expense, rather it's fun to read because we've
been there/done that and feel kindred with the obit writers.
And while one may
read "Obits" with wry amusement, one also may feel a sense of hope, understanding
most of us have walked through similar fires; ya' live/learn/get over it
and, maybe, laugh about it with friends sometime in the future.
As a romance reader, what would make you want to read a book like "Relationship Obits?" Would it be fun -- or horrid! -- to make up obits for the way great romance novel couples' relationships -- horrors! -- ended? Lay some on us...
I'll start:
Darcy and Elizabeth
Cause of Death: Excessive brooding
Survived by: Garrulous mil, silly sils and myriad sequels.
Check this out: Lorraine Heath's Scoundrels twist Dickens in ways they never taught us in school!
Are you reading H2H at a
Barnes&Noble store? Tell me which one,
and what romances you're reading!
- Mark as Read
- Mark Message as New
- Bookmark
- Highlight
- Email to a Friend
- Report Abuse to a Moderator
Intriguing book idea, but your assignment is a hard one!
Rhett and Scarlett
Cause of death: Didn't give a damn, died of apathy
Survived by: Scarlett has been Tara'd and feathered by everyone who loved Rhett. Best skewering was done by Carol Burnett and those glorious draperies.
- Mark as Read
- Mark Message as New
- Bookmark
- Highlight
- Email to a Friend
- Report Abuse to a Moderator
Hey Michelle,
I think I'd be like you -- very skeptical at first. I mean, I don't even like movies where the "death" of a person and/or relationship is supposed to give me a positive life lesson (ala Phenomenon or the old Up Close and Personal). So to purposely explore death or even relationship death would be a big ol' 'uh uh, no thanks.'
That's why well-rounded, open-minded feature columnists like you exist -- to give us gentle cyber smacks upside the head! This book actually sound somewhat cathartic. And I guess just to find a common human experience it would be fun to read.
Thanks for showing us something completely different!
Lizee
- Mark as Read
- Mark Message as New
- Bookmark
- Highlight
- Email to a Friend
- Report Abuse to a Moderator
"Oh, it's just a little somethin' I saw in the window and couldn't resist!" I loved that, Becke! And love 'tara's and feathered..' Did you read Rhett's story from a couple years' back? It was the officially sanctioned novel. I thought the historian male author did a great job, though, oddly enough, it lacked love scenes... hmmm.
Hi Lizee! do you want a job as my publicist? I'm totally w/you on the exploration of death/pain. If I didn't want to avoid it, I wouldn't read romance. Especially after 9/11, the appeal of knowing the worst was coming -- which is as easy a tug on folks' emotions as love stories, but with sub-par sex scenes -- grew tedious. But you're spot on, this book felt really cathartic, and I really felt for the writers who seem really young, understanding what it felt like to lose love at their age, yet looking back from the place of "survival." Yet, since survival isn't all puppies and kitties and big-in-all-ways men, I'm glad we have romance.
- Mark as Read
- Mark Message as New
- Bookmark
- Highlight
- Email to a Friend
- Report Abuse to a Moderator
I tend to side w/Michelle and Lizee. I don't want to see the death of any one in a romance novel but the bad/evil perpetrator etc. definitely not the death of a good love story.
Hmm obits how's this one
Romeo and Juliet
Cause of death (literally): Bad Timing
Survived by: Waring In-Laws and Out-Laws ;-)
Deb
- Mark as Read
- Mark Message as New
- Bookmark
- Highlight
- Email to a Friend
- Report Abuse to a Moderator
LOL - Death by Bad timing -- now THAT's funny (or I'm warped, one of the two).
Michelle -- I'll be your publicist any time. You KNOW how I love your philosophy of life and romance. We do look back on what the young people are going through from a place of "survival" don't we? I think some people call it wisdom--but most days I don't feel very wise. So, yes, thank the good Lord for romance.
I'm having a heck of a time thinking of an obit--always come back to the ones that already ended rather tragically anyway (that fairy tale syndrome again).
How about Arthur and Guinevere?
Cause of Death: Duty
Survived by: A sad wizard, a bloody battlefield and a decaying Round Table.
- Mark as Read
- Mark Message as New
- Bookmark
- Highlight
- Email to a Friend
- Report Abuse to a Moderator
Or Henry the Eighth and Anne Boleyn:
Cause of death: a severed connection
Survived by: War and Peace and the Anglican religion
- Mark as Read
- Mark Message as New
- Bookmark
- Highlight
- Email to a Friend
- Report Abuse to a Moderator
Good one, Deb! In-laws and outlaws. love it. You know I once read a romance where the hero died. but he was a magical selkie and came back to life. Wasn't even like he was "mostly dead,' like in Princess Bride. Anywayz, oddly enough, it was one of the only romances during which I cried. Weird. And, I'm kinda embarrassed to say I cried reading a romance. hmmm....I think that's a blog post for another day, no?
oh, clever, Becke! NerdGirls everywhere applaud you on that one!
Good work on the Arturian obit, Lizee! Poor, sad wizard.
I think folks are chicken to take this one, cause nobody can stand to think of the HEA ending. But you guys, nobody wants to choose a love story that has an HEA and write the obit? tsk tsk tsk. When I point the finger at others on Good Girl Syndrome, it's a sad day indeed.
- Mark as Read
- Mark Message as New
- Bookmark
- Highlight
- Email to a Friend
- Report Abuse to a Moderator
Oh you're all so clever. But what I keep thinking about, is how I could have used (or maybe still use) a romance obit for my own romances throughout my life. I'd like to know, or disect the cause of death of one or two. I need closure damnit! Even now, 30 years later. Wow.
Okay:
Mr. Rochester and Jane Eyre
cause of death: uh, ya think maybe the fact he had his insane wife shut-up in the attic. Love is blind, but not that blind.
survived by: Jane's independence
- Mark as Read
- Mark Message as New
- Bookmark
- Highlight
- Email to a Friend
- Report Abuse to a Moderator
You must be a registered user to add a comment here. If you've already registered, please log in. If you haven't registered yet, please register and log in.
