Back in the spring I attended a conference on romance scholarship at which several academics spoke on topics related to romance fiction and race.  After the presentations, an attendee and I, both white chicks, discussed our multiracial families, and how we thought about race as kids.

I told her I grew up in the time when I heard ugly things like, "He's a credit to his race," and "If you date a black man, no white man will have you."  None of that made sense to me because I was being taught at home exactly from where a human's value was derived.

Yet I remember vividly as a child being puzzled, absolutely sucker-punched when I realized black folks had pets.  I mean, I only saw Lassie and her white family on TV, and all my white friends and their pets, so, I guess my kid logic followed that, while overt racist remarks could be rejected out of hand, what I saw with my own eyes had to be the only possible reality.

So imagine how that perception played out for black kids?  Gwendolyn D. Pough,* Associate Professor of Writing, Rhetoric, Women's and Gender Studies at Syracuse University has done just that, especially as it relates to the positive roles the advent of Black romance fiction has played in the lives of black women.

"Imagine growing up never seeing popular images of healthy loving relationships," says Pough in a guest post today atRomance: B(u)y the Book's Scholars on Romance Week . "Imagine hearing nothing but distortions about your sexuality, having your desire demonized, and hearing nothing but myths about your so-called pathology. Could you hold on to the dream that you would one day find love?"

Pough says before 1994, when Kensington Books created their Arabesque line of romances, "traditional paperback romance novels that showcased black love had been sparse to say the least."   Like romance fiction in general, once begun, Arabesque and lines like Harlequin's Kimani changed lives.

"Most black readers will tell you that they read black romances because they want to be able to relate to the book," states Pough. "They want heroines that look like them."

In addition, Pough believes Black romance novels "perform a kind of activism" because they allow both white and black folks to re-think perceptions. "[Black romances] participate in the re-making of African American images and representations. They offer positive representations of relationships between black men and women. And they also work to rescue the images of black men and women from harmful stereotypes, often rewriting and remixing the stereotypes."

Perhaps most important, Pough believes Black romance provides a message that promotes healing.  Says Pough, "[Black romance works] to disprove myths about black love and black people's capabilities to love and worthiness to be loved."

How important is it for you to be able to identify with the characters in a romance novel?  Who are some of your favorite authors of African American and multicultural romance?  Are there romances sold near you with folks on the cover who look different from you -- and what makes you want to buy them?

 

 

*Gwendolyn D. Pough says Arabesque romances helped her realize she could have a career in academia as well as fulfillher other dream: Pough writes romance fiction as Gwenyth Bolton. Check our her new read, "Sizzling Seduction," and herHightower series. She's also the author of "Check It While I Wreck It: Black Womanhood, Hip-Hop Culture and the Public Sphere "  as well as numerous essays and articles on black feminism, hip-hop, critical pedagogy and black public culture.

Comments
by Moderator becke_davis on 09-26-2009 11:38 AM

I think it's important to be able to relate to the characters in a romance, but that doesn't mean I only read romances where the heroine is a fifty-something white American woman. I read romance for the emotional connection, and since I usually put myself inside the heroine's head, race isn't really an issue. And I will sometimes make a point of choosing a book that features a heroine with a completely different background than mine, just because it makes it more interesting.

by 1lovealways on 09-27-2009 01:46 AM

Hi Michelle!  It is important to relate to the characters in a romance, but I don't necessarily read romances based on the race of the characters.  Being from a multiracial family, personally I believe that love has no color and this carries over to my romance reading I guess.  Honestly, I've never thought about it until now.  I've read romances by black authors and I've enjoyed them as immensely as the ones I've read by white authors.

 

Some of my favorite African American authors are Sandra Kitt (a long time favorite), Monica White and Bernadette Parkin.  Ms. Parkin had a book entitled Nate's Lady, a historical romance published in 1981 by Avon Books.  This was a good book.  In fact, I still have it as part of my keepers.  It had a beautiful cover!

 

There are lots of romances with people on the cover that look different than I do, but this doesn't bother me.  When I read a romance, I'm looking for that connection between the hero and heroine that leads to emotional sparks and these sparks eventually  lead to love.  That's what interests me!  I buy romances based on authors I've read before or recommendations from other readers.  I also buy them based on the blurb on the back of the book.  If that catches my interests along with setting, plot, and time period, then I buy the book.  Again, It has nothing to do with the color of the author for me! :smileyhappy:

 

 

 

 If an author is a good writer and can grab and sustain my attention, be they black or white, then I'll buy their book. 

by Author LeeRhuday on 09-28-2009 10:34 AM
Michelle, this is Leigh singing in from my Iphone at the W Melbourne Barnes and Noble.
by Author LeeRhuday on 09-28-2009 10:40 AM
MIchelle, I think I'll stop at the phone store on the way home to see if there's a connection we can buy so we can type on the laptop but access the site through the phone. What do you think?
by Author LeeRhuday on 09-28-2009 11:03 AM

This is Leigh, signing in from Kaori's computer!

by Moderator becke_davis on 09-28-2009 11:09 AM

I'm here, too, checking in from Cincinnati.

by Author MonicaBurns on 09-28-2009 11:42 AM

You know, I could care less what color, race, breed, ethnicity in general a character is. The only thing I want is to be immersed in the story and appreciate it. When I'm reading, I'm in the heroine's head most of the time anyway, so that makes her a plump woman with a need for a gorgeous alpha male. I don't care what culture the hero is from. If he's gorgeous, I'll take him.

 

Besides, it's fun to read about different cultures where I learn something. While the Joy Luck club wasn't a romance, it was a wonderful look into Asian cultures. Michelle Moran's new book Cleopatra's Daughter is another look into a culture that's rich with all types of historical info. And I'm already hot for Juba in that book.

 

I don't base my buying on what something is or isn't supposed to be. I buy the story.

by Moderator becke_davis on 09-28-2009 11:47 AM

The Joy Luck Club was a wonderful book. It was one of those books that so totally sucked me into the culture, it took me several days to shake it off and feel like I was completely back in my own world.

by on 09-28-2009 11:26 PM

Yep defiantly The Joy Luck Club... very good book.

 

by Blogger Michelle_Buonfiglio on 10-01-2009 06:50 PM

What great thoughts, 1lovealways.  You make me wish I had that book!  I've gotta tell you, if I see a book with a cover depicting folks other than the kinds of  Anglo-ish folks we generally see on covers, I race toward it. Some of that's about my eye being attracted to things that are 'different,' but there's also a "yay, finally!" factor.  One of the things lots of us hope for is the time when covers in the Romance Section depict people of many colors as a rule.  In the mean time, there are issues about marketing and selling books for authors vs 'ghetto-izing' authors/books. Tough, tough issues.

 

But I think what folks in the industry have figured out, unfortunately, is that, while folks of color don't have much problem reading across the aisle, as it were, the opposite just doesn't happen that often.  Why?  That's what we want to know and fix at the grass-roots level. I think it's about access and education.  Intro folks to things that are 'different,' give them the language w/which to talk about them and let them know what they're about, especially, in this case, that in terms of 'general romance,' the love story construct always is the same no matter who's writing or what color/ethnicity the characters.

by Blogger Michelle_Buonfiglio on 10-01-2009 06:54 PM - last edited on 10-01-2009 06:54 PM

Mon, Becke and TiggerBear, Amy Tan does an incredible job of translating Asian culture -- and Asian American culture -- for we non-Asians.  She's marvelous in terms of allowing us to feel the strenght of Asian woman who've often been viewed in Western society as weak, subservient, submissive or exotically sensual playthings.  She also lets us see some brutal  mother/daughter and female relationships in Asian culture that translate pretty easily to American women. 

by Blogger Michelle_Buonfiglio on 10-01-2009 07:05 PM

You've made the perfect point, Mon: the story's the thing. And for those who adore other cultures, the fact that more romances w/other cultural flavors are being published is like heading to the buffet.

 

I think some readers, however, get stuck in concern that they won't feel 'welcome' in the culture of a book.  Someone once said in a comment 'I can read vampires and werewolves, why can't I enjoy another race?"  And I understand that point.  But the problem inAmerica is, Vamps/weres/etc don't have a hundreds-of-years-old history of racism.  I think there is a natural discomfort among some white folks who are not racist but don't know anything about what they think is black culture, and expect they'll need to know something about it to enjoy the romances.  They expect dialogue or slang, perhaps, or storylines that deal with realities of being black in America, and simply don't know how to process that.

Now, it's a good thing, I think, that they expect there may be something different about black culture, because it means they are allowing that black folks don't have to be homogeneous and fit in and aren't just white folks w/differnt colored skin. So perhaps publishers of multicultural and aa romances could spend a little energy and marketing dollars educating readers about exactly what their multicultural and aa romances are and aren't.  Or they can just lament the fact that white folks don't read across the aisles.  

by 1lovealways on 10-01-2009 11:06 PM

Hi Michelle!  I think Nate's Lady is still in print.  I wish I could send you a pic of the original cover.  The hero is to die for!  You know publishers change the covers.  And knowing how old that book is, I'm sure it has been changed.  Unfortunately, I'm not that technologically advanced.  I have a printer that I'm still trying to figure out how to hook up!  :smileyhappy: