04-18-2008 12:14 AM
04-18-2008 05:00 AM
yavanna wrote:No Problem LorienI agree with you on the creation story. It is arguably one of the most beautiful tale ever written imho. This is also why some people gave Silmarillion the title "The 'Bible' of Middle Earth" Yes, I was kinda lost in the later part too. So once this book club starts on The Silmarillion, it'll be a good chance for me to re-cap hehe! I do own a copy of the Unfinished Tales too, but sad to say that I've just started on the book. I hope I can slowly catch up with you guys because I read quite slow. Thanks for the sharing and I hope I didn't turn this thread into The Silmarillion thread ><
04-18-2008 11:04 AM - edited 04-18-2008 11:33 AM
yavanna wrote:No Problem LorienI agree with you on the creation story. It is arguably one of the most beautiful tale ever written imho. This is also why some people gave Silmarillion the title "The 'Bible' of Middle Earth" Yes, I was kinda lost in the later part too. So once this book club starts on The Silmarillion, it'll be a good chance for me to re-cap hehe! I do own a copy of the Unfinished Tales too, but sad to say that I've just started on the book. I hope I can slowly catch up with you guys because I read quite slow. Thanks for the sharing and I hope I didn't turn this thread into The Silmarillion thread >
Actually, we did have a Silmarillion thread on the old board but it didn't get transfered--but there wasn't much there. We are not scheduled for the Silm yet but I'm beginning to think some discussion of it is a necessity. I know as I read parts of it, I have encountered some minor points that I would not mind bringing up to the group, though mostly they have been within context of other threads.
Message Edited by lorien on 04-18-2008 11:33 AM
04-20-2008 11:42 AM
Hi there My name's Jenny! I first started reading LOTR 5-6 years ago after I watched the first instalment of the movies by Peter Jackson. Thereafter, I really fell in love with Tolkien's work and I proceeded to read The Hobbit and then The Silmarillion. I'm ashamed to say that I've only read LOTR once and therefore I consider myself new to Tolkien's work. Really excited about joining you guys and reading the wonderful books again!
Welcome to the Tolkien discussion group. Great to see newcomers joining us and providing more points of view on subjects. You seem to be ready for the group -- you read the body of work once and are now ready to delve into the the detail and analysis. I'm looking forward to your comments.
04-28-2008 12:11 PM
04-28-2008 08:43 PM
macross wrote:Hellop my name is Jean(pronounced John) I first read LOTR at 15 and read it at least twice a year, Ive read the hobbit also and The Silmarillion. I also play Lord of the Rings Online.
Hi Jean. You must be French. Nice to have you with us. As you can see we tend to take different outlooks on things. After all your readings of LOTR, you will probably like to join some of our numerous subject threads as we explore different aspects of Tolkien's writing. There is a lot to explore here.
04-28-2008 11:36 PM
You know the Hobbit is coming out on a movie directed by peter jackson and the simirillion
Tolkien is my favorite author as well
One Ring to find them
One Ring to bring them all and in darkness bind them
04-29-2008 06:35 AM
04-29-2008 12:14 PM - edited 04-29-2008 12:18 PM
Welcome Tolkien. I'm sure you will fit right in! You might give us a bit of information on your background with Tolkien's works. Are you a beginner or have you been reading Tolkien regularly for years now? And what have you read of his? I am sure you will bring some unique perspectives to our group. Hope you enjoy participating.
Message Edited by lorien on 04-29-2008 12:18 PM
05-04-2008 03:20 PM
macross wrote:Lorien haha I am not french, I am Puertorrican, but my full name is french, Jean Pierre.
How did a Puerto Rican (I can't roll my r's!) acquire a French name?
05-06-2008 02:13 PM
05-06-2008 02:48 PM
Anyway, I cant think of a more enjoyable way to spend a lazy spring/summer/autumn/winter evening.
And it will take that long at the rate we move! Welcome to our discussion. If you want to start with The Hobbit or Lord of the Rings or just jump in where ever, go right ahead. We basically have two types of threads: the chapter read-alongs where we try to maintain some sort of forward moving schedule and avoid spoilers for those who might be reading the books for the first time. And we have topic threads--lots of those. Anyone can start a topic, so if you don't see a topic you are interested in in our several pages of thread headers, go ahead and start a new one. Most of us just started The Two Towers, but all the other threads are open for discussion, and you will find us going back to them all the time. We have a very loose schedule. After we finish going through LOTR (maybe around next September) we will probably take up the Silmarillion.
We are a very friendly group with very broad interests, so you will find a wide diversity of interests here. We are courteous and respect the opinions of others. I think you will find this an ideal group for discussions of all things Tolkien.
LadyKatrina40 wrote:Hello!I actually signed up for this group and then forgot my sign up information! The Hobbit and LOTR are my favorite books of all time. I vaguely remember reading it in school but I cant be sure. Sometimes youth is wasted on the young! Anyway, I cant think of a more enjoyable way to spend a lazy spring/summer/autumn/winter evening.I recently left a group because of the disparaging remarks made about Christianity and Christ. While I am a Christian, I dont force my beliefs on others. I do however take offense to the way my Saviors name was treated with such open disrespect. So, I decided to look for another group!I love all things Tolkien. I love reading his biography and watching the DVD's pertaining to his life and work.
05-08-2008 09:46 AM
05-08-2008 10:15 PM
LadyKatrina40 wrote:Thanks for the welcome! I look forward to jumping right in. I am also halfway through the Two Towers! I took a side trip back to the Shire last week. For some reason, I wanted to listen to The Hobbit on CD. But I'm back and now I'm ready to make the long trek through Middle Earth!
I actually like listening to these books on CD better than reading the text, though I end up doing both. Tolkien has such a way with language. In the reading you don't pick up the rhythm of the speech, the alliteration, or the sound of the words. I think it is important to hear his languages actually spoken. they suit the personality of the beings associated with the language and each has an individual sound. Plus on the CD you get to hear the songs sung and I think it works well because Inglis is not a professional singer. I even got the CD with Tolkien reading from his own books and singing some of his songs. It is all sorts of fun to hear the master performing his own works.
I have the unabridged Inglis and I think he does an excellent job of creating the different voices. I also have the BBC dramatization, but I haven't warmed up to that yet. It is also very abridged. I think the BBC might have been lots of fun with The Hobbit, though, but it doesn't seem to be available any more.
Which one are you listening to?
05-09-2008 08:36 AM
05-11-2008 09:14 AM
Welcome to the Tolkien group. This will be a lovely place to spend the summer. Well, you do seem to be a Tolkien fan so you have come to the right place. I hope you find this reading of LOTR rewarding and I'm looking forward to your insight.
05-12-2008 09:19 AM
07-26-2008 08:34 PM
Hi all. I am excited to have found this group! I love all of the Tolkien books. I return to them every year or two for another read. Neither my husband nor my kids shares my love of Tolkien, so I am happy to have found this reading group!