I dont know if this will be helpful but the front cover has a blond girl in a red & white shirt. There is a picture of a sailboat in the background and possibly a lighthouse. The writers name is in light blue no aqua. I thought the title had the word Island but I cant seem to find anything with Island that matches the picture. Also, I remember that Luke & Holly were stranded somewhere over night and they declare their feelings. Once they get back home and Luke sees how worried Robbie was, he decided to back off. He told Holly " when you cant be with the one you love then love the one you're with" Luke then gets engaged to Paige but Holly is surprised that the ring he gives her isnt the family herloom. Something happens to Holly, hits her head or something...and as she goes unconscience, she hears Luke yelling at Robbie about the woman he loves.
