- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Mark as New
- Mark as Read
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Email to a Friend
- Printer Friendly Page
- Report Abuse to a Moderator
My home is filled with books. In every room, bookshelves of various shapes and sizes are filled to capacity. Check that: They're over capacity. Additional books lie on tables and couches, as well as under tables and couches. You get the picture. I've been writing about business and technology (among other things) for over 40 years and teaching journalism at several universities for 20 years; naturally, wherever I go I'm surrounded by books. Many of these volumes have followed me from Michigan to Florida to Washington, D.C. to California and beyond.
To date, I’ve only read a portion of my total collection; many I have intended to read for a long time, but (to be realistic) probably never will. These are my aspirational books, you might say. Of those I've read, perhaps 10 percent -- or a couple hundred -- have influenced me beyond measure. These are the books I’ve purchased multiple times throughout my journeys; I often give away copies to students, friends, and even casual acquaintances when the impulse strikes. So I reside inside a self-curated library of sorts, an environment that I've more or less replicated whenever and wherever I've relocated, which has been roughly a dozen times over the past four decades.
But lately, something about this very intimate part of my life has started to change. As I was sitting in my living room with a friend recently, contemplating all of my books, my friend suggested that these books actually are relics of a bygone era. Technology has rendered my propensity to collect print volumes a rather quaint trait. Global climate change has rendered it ecologically unsound. And the cost of space in San Francisco has rendered it ultimately unsustainable.
eBook reading devices like nook are capable of holding all of the books I own -- and desire to own -- in a unit about the size of a paperback. Thus, I could (and probably should) downsize this library of mine and make it mobile. In the process, I could reduce my personal carbon footprint, as well as free up lots of space at home and on the road.
Plus, my friend suggested that day, I could sell some of these books, and make enough to cover the cost of a new eReader (and then some). Her logic was flawless, of course, and it set me down a path that would have been unimaginable even a year or two ago: selling or giving away most of my collection.
I'm almost resolved to making this bold move, but it's hard. Many of these volumes evoke moments and feelings that are still vivid, though long past; some from tropical days reading in India and Malaysia, others from chilly nights in Russia and Japan. How can I just let go of these memories?
I guess a digital library is something I'll have to build gradually over time, like I did with print books. When I think of it that way, it's doesn't seem like such a radical step. Besides, I'm pretty sure I'll keep my memories forever.
I wonder if you're feeling the same way. Where are you on the path from print to digital?
- Mark as Read
- Mark Message as New
- Bookmark
- Highlight
- Email to a Friend
- Report Abuse to a Moderator
Aren't you getting ahead of yourself? Considering the amount of eBooks not available, you will be forgoing a lot of your library. I think you definitely need to phase this, keeping pulp until the eBook is available, right?
- Mark as Read
- Mark Message as New
- Bookmark
- Highlight
- Email to a Friend
- Report Abuse to a Moderator
This post is completely wrong-headed. The brilliance of mp3 players was that you could have your CD collection at home and also take your music out with you on a convenient, portable device. It didn't make you choose between one or the other. You could buy the actual CD and put the music on your digital player. Books are even more permanent than CDs or DVDs. When you buy a book, you know that it will exist for years, that it will follow you around your whole life, that a book you bought in your 20's can be passed down to your kids some day. I don't want my entire book collection to be the victim of the theft or destruction of a single device. You can't really display your back-up files the way you can display your CD or DVD collection. The demographic for these ereaders are people who love their books, who have read (and reread) every single book on their selves. We want the convenience and portability of an ebook reader, but we still want our physical books. There's no reason you can't sell a physical book and include a digital copy (except, maybe, greed). I for one will continue buying physical books and simply download the digital copies from pirate sites until retailers finally figure out what the book buying public actually wants.
- Mark as Read
- Mark Message as New
- Bookmark
- Highlight
- Email to a Friend
- Report Abuse to a Moderator
Yeah, I've gotta say that you're leaving out a pretty big caveat here, and one that is still my biggest beef with getting an eReader:
Sure, selling all your books to cover the cost of the nook would work just great, but, then you're gonna pay the full blown price for each of their ebook counterparts? And, as andrewe rightfully points out, it's likely that not even all of your books are available in ebook format.
My problem here is that I've got close to a hundred physical books that I've yet to read, plus maybe a hundred more that I *have* read. If I buy an eReader today, then I'd want a way to get all of them, unread ones most preferably, on to my device, *without* having to purchase them again.
Furthermore, I'm a big Half Price Books fan, and well, there's no secondary market for ebooks is there?
What someone (Amazon, B&N, doesn't matter) needs to offer is a trade-in program, whereby you can trade in your physical books (which are definitely worth more than their ebook cousins) in exchange for their ebook counterparts. The physical books could easily be resold at a slight discount, and the user of the eReader comes away happy by being able to reduce his carbon footprint via offloading dead-tree books so that they can then have them all contained on one nice, slick device.
Thoughts?
- Mark as Read
- Mark Message as New
- Bookmark
- Highlight
- Email to a Friend
- Report Abuse to a Moderator
As has been noted, you guys have a long way to go before you can talk about going all-ebook. The tipping point will be reached when a publisher tries to restrict what you can do, and you can tell them "Fine, no deal" and they cave in. I'm guessing we aren't there yet, judging by the DRM and whatnot.
As for me, I am *so* looking forward to the day when all my books can be e-books! I have absolutely no sentimentality about huge bricks of wood pulp. Those people who say "Oh, there's just something special about a book!": yeah, there was something special about outdoor toilets, too. Good riddance to both.
- Mark as Read
- Mark Message as New
- Bookmark
- Highlight
- Email to a Friend
- Report Abuse to a Moderator
Thanks for your comments, guys. As I hoped to imply, I'm deeply ambiguous about this transition, and therefore sure to be acting slowly. By nature, I think about things quite a bit before acting, and I don't even have my first eReader yet. But, on the basis of logic alone, the day for me to act is coming. I cannot continue to sustain this large collection of books that hardly anyone ever uses any longer.
One thing I left out of the post is that a number of the books will be donated to non-profits and schools. I've been able to identify those that could be useful to these institutions and now I just have to haul them away. So they will find new homes.
But also the upside to devices like the nook and others is that a huge volume of books is becoming available, and thanks to massive scanning efforts like that by Google, many more will presumably be viewable soon. Therefore, on all of those occasions I am mobile, the books I want and/or need can travel with me.
- Mark as Read
- Mark Message as New
- Bookmark
- Highlight
- Email to a Friend
- Report Abuse to a Moderator
I have a Kindle app on my iPhone and I love it because if I ever get a free moment, I can get a little reading done -- on a re-read of an old favorite or on a book I've been meaning to read for ages -- without lugging the book around in my purse. Amazon even has some free e-book downloads, either of promotional books (like the first one in a series to hook you) or of classics like Pride & Prejudice and collections of Sherlock Holmes mysteries. (I sound like an ad for Amazon's Kindle... I so am not, fyi, because I don't want to buy the actual Kindle. I'm very content with the Kindle app for iPhones.)
However, I know that I will never give up hard or soft copies of books. I do limit myself to only purchasing/keeping decorative art or photo books and books that have had a huge impact on my life. I will no longer be buying the Next Hot New Book You Have To Read... instead I'll read it on my app and if it is something I'll want to read again and again, maybe I'll purchase the actual book.
I love that you're donating the books. I've always been very involved with organizing book drives in the past and it's important for any and all types of reading material to be available to everyone... and I'm sure no organization would turn away a book. Even Salvation Army would love to have them.
Good luck with your transition!
- Mark as Read
- Mark Message as New
- Bookmark
- Highlight
- Email to a Friend
- Report Abuse to a Moderator
I think that e-books are perfectly suited to the new mobile life many of are living these days; we don't stay in one house, one city, or even one country for our whole lives or careers, and a huge library of paper books doesn't fit into that reality. On the other hand, paper will have a place in my reading for a long time to come -- just a diminishing one. Thanks for the thoughtful post.
- Mark as Read
- Mark Message as New
- Bookmark
- Highlight
- Email to a Friend
- Report Abuse to a Moderator
I would love to do that, but at this point, I can't entirely trust that (a) the books I want will be available in ebook format and (b) that I will truly OWN the ebooks that I buy. I think we were all spooked when Amazon removed certain H.G. Wells books from readers' Kindles. That illustrated how closely tied we are to the "cloud" and how quickly that can be abused. Although I have no reason to think that B7N or any other vendor would do that (I think Amazon learned its lesson), I also have no reason to think that they won't. The fact that they have that power is disconcerting, and the lack of permanence of ebooks is a major flaw that has to be addressed before the masses take such a drastic step.
That said, I plan to be one of the first nook owners, and I look forward to the digital revolution of the printed word, assuming it's done right.
- Mark as Read
- Mark Message as New
- Bookmark
- Highlight
- Email to a Friend
- Report Abuse to a Moderator
@jasonact: it was Orwell they removed, which is about Orwellian as you can get. You are hereby sentenced to listen to Alanis Morrissette's "Ironic". ![]()
- Mark as Read
- Mark Message as New
- Bookmark
- Highlight
- Email to a Friend
- Report Abuse to a Moderator
I really like your post because it presents a view that I think a lot of people who love to collect books struggle with. Would you feel like you'd be betraying the romantic idea of a good, classic book with the new or old smell of its pages by moving towards a new electronic form? I know that's what I'm struggling with. As an English major in my 3rd year I obviously have to, and like to, read a lot. My personal collection, while its not as large as yours, is still a collection. There are at least 15 or 20 that I recently got at used book sales and therefore virtually paid hardly any money for, and others are ones that I've treasured over the years, such as the infamous Harry Potter collection and Jane Austen's novels. I don't travel a lot, so one part of my mind says I don't have a use for the nook. I have to admit though, Barnes & Noble has done a good job of making it attractive because I may be a book lover, but I'm also a tech nerd and I do love sleek objects with pretty screens ;o) While I walk to classes and ride the bus, I have my iPod in my ears. The irony? I'm usually listening to audiobooks, as I don't really have time to read for pleasure during the school year because I'm doing so much assigned reading. Would an e-reader make me more committed to physically reading during downtime? I don't know, I usually give myself the guilt trip for reading when I know I have homework or studying to do.
I feel like the electronic way of living is the direction we're all headed, but that doesn't mean you have to commit to it 100%. Keep those special books that have memories attached to them or that really chaged you in some way. But others, those books you bought on a whim or for a quick read, whether you ever ended up reading them or not, sell or donate those. And later, after you have some kind of e-reader as I imagine you will, and you come across books like that again, download them instead. I think if I end up getting one at some point that's whay I'll try to do, but I could never give up paper books entirely.
- Mark as Read
- Mark Message as New
- Bookmark
- Highlight
- Email to a Friend
- Report Abuse to a Moderator
I agree with booksntea that this is not an issue that needs a 100% commitment. In an ideal world I would be happy to read books unburdened by a physical form but have that 10% that is important to me on a shelf - for browsing, for lending, as a conversation starter.
However the present system kind of makes it hard because in such a case you would have to buy the book twice - once to e-read and once to put on your shelf - at wtice the full price. I have trouble understanding why if I pay full price for the e-book I can't have the dead tree version for a nominal price, and vice versa.
- Mark as Read
- Mark Message as New
- Bookmark
- Highlight
- Email to a Friend
- Report Abuse to a Moderator
Thanks, again, to all of you who are participating in this discussion. "Booksntea," I especially appreciate the sentiments you are expressing. We seem to be living in an all-or-nothing world, sometimes, where the extremes appear to dominate. But, as one who has been covering the media industry broadly over the past few years, I have easily seen as many examples of how technology is helping to preserve physical books and magazines as it is to destroying them, and I hope to post about that here in the future.
I honestly think that the jury is out on every relevant question posed in this thread. We do not yet know whether any eReader devices can replicate the sensual pleasure of a physical book. And even if one can, whether that is what we want to happen, as a community. The point is that those of us who love to read books in whatever form can still have an enormous influence over how this turns out, which is a very good thing.
- Mark as Read
- Mark Message as New
- Bookmark
- Highlight
- Email to a Friend
- Report Abuse to a Moderator
In an old Steve Martin comedy special on TV, he visits the National Library of Comedy. When he arrives, he finds the shelves empty; everything has been reduced to fit on a piece of microfiche the size of a pea. Steve Martin tries to read it, but accidentally sets it on fire, destroying the single copy.
So... let's say you've converted your paper books to ebooks. What happens when something happens to the nook and you cannot access your books? How easy is it to backup the files on the nook?
You could have a library registry on BN.com which would allow you to reload the titles, but do you really want anyone else to know what you are reading?
I read PDFs at work and on my TREO. I own a lot of comics and graphic novels. While digital files make it easier to locate something by keyword, I usually find it easier to thumb through a paper catalog or magazine. (By flipping through a book, I'll probably find something else of interest, which will lead to other random connections.) I prefer books, but have no prejudices against reading something on a screen. I'll probably purchase an iPad next year, since numerous comics are already available at the Apple store, and it will have web access, a color screen, and play a variety of media.
- Mark as Read
- Mark Message as New
- Bookmark
- Highlight
- Email to a Friend
- Report Abuse to a Moderator
I'm a little from column "a" and a little from column "b" here. I love books. And, while I do keep books, I don't consider myself a collector of books. I keep them because I love the physicality of them, I love the feel of them, and I love to look at my shelves and see what I've read.
I love to pick one up I'd forgotten all about and flip through it. I love watching my kids peruse the shelves and select something to read (fun to watch them move up in complexity and subject matter). I love lending things to friends that stop by.
That said, with the upcoming release of the Nook (which I pre-ordered), I'm finally excited about eBooks (not to mention newspapers and magazines like my beloved Reason). I'm just not sure if it's the tech-lover in me or the reader that's excited; perhaps both. I can tell you this though: while I'll probably buy quite a few eBooks, that's not going to keep me from buying actual books (plus I get a lot of ARCs for review, which is great).
And neither those new books, nor my current library, are going anywhere.
- Mark as Read
- Mark Message as New
- Bookmark
- Highlight
- Email to a Friend
- Report Abuse to a Moderator
Yikes! Your bookshelf is about half as full as mine. I have books shelved in front of books in the back. Which isn't the best arrangement to have for books but until I start passing them onto the library donation bin, that's what I've got for now.
As far as the "climate change" argument for going to digital rather than print - yes, digital spares hundreds of thousands of trees having to be cut down to bind and sell the latest Danielle Steel monstrosity, but do you really think electronic books are the environmentally sound answer? The amount of toxic chemicals that goes into creating the screens, circuits, wireless cards, batteries, and the inevitable "e-waste" all these flashy e-readers will one day turn into I'm sure are just as punishing to the environment as paper is.
You must be a registered user to add a comment here. If you've already registered, please log in. If you haven't registered yet, please register and log in.
