A while back I chatted with a university prof who studies women's issues and pop culture, a smart, personable, way-reasonable ladyA strong romance fiction supporter, she says she's got no beef with describing erotic romance as porn

While the First Amendment-huggin' part of me likes her idea of not demonizing adult entertainment - and allowing chicks the right to revel in depictions of sexuality for the simple sake of libidinal arousal - I think erotic romance and adult entertainment generally fulfill entirely different, n'er-the-twain-shall-meet needs...

 

Even when we dress up adult film in "story" -- the newer "women's erotica" films, for example, in which we view a couple having sex interspersed with B roll of their clothed selves telling their "how we met" stories -- we're still watching the flick simply to experience sexual arousal

We also read erotic romance novels (erom) expecting to become aroused. In erom, scenes of sensual and sexual play occur frequently and generally are depicted with graphic language and imagery .

Yet the erom fan also demands sex in the erotic romance be linked inextricably with the formation and growth of an intense emotional bond between the lovers depictedSensuality in erotic romance necessarily moves the story forward as partners use their sexual exploration to build relational connectivity in the same way sexual tension and relational interaction is used in less-sensual romances.

That said, don't think for a moment I and others don't turn to favorite erotic romances the way some guys I know seek out certain Jenna Jameson downloadsI mean, there are 30 or 40 strategically dog-eared pages of Emma Holly's upcoming "Kissing Midnight  " that I regularly reach for in ways that probably would alter anybody's definition of the term comfort read.

But here's the rub, as it wereI may get off on the scenes, but I've already absorbed the love story Holly's laid out for me, how the shape-shifting vampire hero's adored the heroine for years, how his rapacious craving for her is heightened by the way her humanity affects his newly awakened ability to fiercely love a being other than his adopted children.

And if you read romance, you dig just how much more sexy that makes Edmund Fitz Clare and anything he and his bigol vampire body can do to a woman.

So, if we can pull out of context and read a scene from an erotic romance and get hot, and we use porn for the same reason, aren't they one and the sameI asked this question of author Portia Da Costa, an author whose exceptional work is influential in the worlds of American as well as British erotic romance.

"Basically," says Da Costa, "I just let people classify books and stories how they want to, and as long as they're enjoying what they read in the way they want to enjoy it, I'm happy with that."

Quite reasonable, considering how we've talked around Unabashedly Bookish of  lines between genres and subgenres blending.  In Portia's case, you can make your own call when you check out an 18+ only excerpt from Portia's delicious upcoming erom, "Kiss It Better  ."  But I predict you'll get a grand idea of how erotic romance weaves a spell of sensuality with a promise of the relational commitment that will develop through sexual exploration.

Yikers. I may have confused rather than clarified the porn vs erotic romance debate.  But let's review anyway: Love develops when partners connect emotionally and experience relational growth toward commitment while exploring joyfully shared sensual pleasure

 

Yeah, my thoughts exactly; romance is just so unrealistic.

If they both are created to get you hot, are porn and erotic romance the same beastHow do they differWhat do you love about erotic romance? What are some of your faves?
Message Edited by Michelle_Buonfiglio on 05-12-2009 04:20 PM
Message Edited by Michelle_Buonfiglio on 05-13-2009 07:26 PM
Comments
by Author MonicaBurns on 05-15-2009 10:52 AM

@KathyS - Thanks Doll!! I should have figured that one out! :smileyvery-happy: I was thinking there was some magic wand Michelle had that she was using.

 

 

by on 05-15-2009 11:24 AM

Monica, you're welcome...I'm sure Michelle is waving her magic wand over us, but in the case of little emoticons, that wand belongs to you. :\

 

BTW, if you put a quote within a parenthesis, give the right patenthesis a space after the quote mark, or you'll get one of these dumb winky ones  ")  In this blog format, us peons have no editing function....it will wink at you for life!  And people will read it and say, "Huh, wusthatfor?"

 

K.

by Blogger Michelle_Buonfiglio on 05-16-2009 12:17 PM

KathyS, thanks for the help with the smilies.  I never knew how to do them all.  Way back in '06 when I started my RBTB blog, Monica had to drag me kicking and screaming into the 90s by fronting my a copy of online acronyms.  Like, who knew rothflmao meant something good?  It is true, as you say, that cover images and titles can be as frustrating for consumers as for authors.  It's a delicate balance that takes some consideration, the idea that the way publishers market and sell books tends to help us all in the long term: authors sell books so they can write more, we get to read more of the books we love and support more authors. Lots of hiccups and glitches and flat out disasters in the process.  But then, the course of  true love(stories) never did run smooth, I guess... :smileytongue:  Hey! The icon thing worked! Thanks!

 

Yes, Mon, this is a discussion I easily could have with you for hours, I think.  I was saying that if we say that porn is pretty much the sole stuff of men's fantasy, then by rejecting out of hand "porn" as being devoid of anything healthy or positive we're first being naive about what even healthy men fantasize about and how they connect sex/intimacy/love and second making the same sweeping statement about every bit of another form of entertainment that folks make about ours

 

Third --and you touched on this a bit -- I'm wondering if we're not afraid to open a can o worms by possibly admitting that some erotica runs a little close to simply being about turning on the reader.  We may know the inner emotional workings of the characters, but if the scene/story is a drive-by hook up w/no hea in sight, does the mere fact that we consider the art of writing more refined than the ability to work a digital recorder make the former art and the latter porn?  And do we consider where the story is published to be the decisive factor in delineating porn from erotica?  Because I remind you that not too many years ago, some folks considered e-pubbed erotic romance 'less than' paperback pubbed fiction, and not just cause it was digitally pubbed, but because of the "graphic" sensuality.

 

See what I'm sayin'?  I'm making arguments because I like to be thoughtful about stuff, and one question usually leads me to another.   I'm certainly not advocating pornography as a replacement for intimacy.  Nor do I advocate reading erotic romance, erotica or romance in general in the same way for women.  While we often point to the ways reading romance can enhance the 'love lives' of women who read it, it also can be used by women to ignore lack of intimacy in their lives.  I certainly believe it empowers more women than anything else, but like anything that feels great, it can become addictive and be used to sooth pain.   My information on that only is anecdotal. But perhaps that would be an interesting study: Have you ever had to cut back your romance readingso you could concentrate on your relationship/s? 

by Blogger Michelle_Buonfiglio on 05-16-2009 12:26 PM

Hi, Debbie:  Like you, I always feel way more comfortable when there's sex in the relationship depicted because it feels more realistic to me.  It's such a healthy part of the maturation of any relationship, especially a new one.  Even in some of the new Inspirational romance, authors address and celebrate the sexual tension between their characters  and present it as healthy and a gift from  God. (Inspirational romance, for those of you who might not be familiar, is romance based in Christian beliefs with varying levels of religious content, reference to liturgy, etc.).  The cool thing about that is it allows younger readers to understand their sexualities in a positive way while giving them support if they're also practicing the type of relationships described in the novels. 

 

That's part of the great beauty of romance, there seems to be a novel written for everyone that celebrates a particular sexuality, sexual comfort level, style, predilection, taste.  Each of those novels says: You're ok just the way you are with the sexuality, sexual fantasies and desires you own.  Love and be loved and be ok and wonderful with who you are.

by Blogger Michelle_Buonfiglio on 05-16-2009 12:29 PM

becke, I love hearing your take on the great authors and why you like em.  I'm quite happy w/all styles of writing, but I must say that the hero's point of view (pov) makes the book and the genre for me.  It's part of the fantasy: We get to know what a guy's thinking and, wouldn't you know?, he's thinking exactly the way we'd want our guys to think of us! 

 

 

by Blogger Michelle_Buonfiglio on 05-16-2009 12:49 PM

hi, stacy1.  I like you you put this: I always think of porn as the more selfish act, primarily concerned with one's own pleasure, instead of wanting both characters to be having a good time.  It's about feeling good physically and emotionally.  That is very enticing, isn't it, when reading a sensual or erotic romance, knowing how much more satisfied one or both partners is when they realize how fulfilling making love is when they're sharing the pleasure?  such a good point you've made.

 

tiggerbear, a bear after my own heart.  I get nervous if I can't classify something.  That's why I'm always asking you all for your input! :smileyhappy:

 

Hi, Portia!  Truly: cake; love; sex.  What could be better?  Yes . It's chocolate cake.

 

cake and packages, ames?  hmmm.  I have to say, though, I've read some erom that's left me feeling ooky. To me that means that it's bringing up something for me that I've not come to terms with, or simply doesn't arouse me sexually. But I know it arouses someone else and usually launches into some long consideration about what makes that thing arousing and before I know it I've wasted a ton of time surfing the Inet for info. Sometimes I wish I could just stop thinking However, visual pornography is really hard to assimilate and can get ooky fast, probably faster for chicks than guys, though I'm no expert.

 

hi, eva.  This is going to sound silly, but, I'm wondering what not emotionally satisfying might be.  I know some people don't like a story with a 'soft' happily ever after. They want marriage, engagement.  Other's just want 'optimistic,' like "we're going to live together and hope for the best.'   I'm thinking about erotica w/no commitment and, as I said to monica, just a hook up.  If both partners only want that, I guess what would be considered 'emotionally satisfying' for them and a certain category of reader. But I think other readers might shove that right into the 'pornography' category.  I'm not trying to shoot you down, just trying to say that the slippery slope that makes it difficult for the courts to define pornography also might affect our view, too. Thoughts?

by on 05-16-2009 02:34 PM

This is funny, Michelle, you mentioning  liking, "what the guy is thinking".  My thoughts on this. 

 

That book I mentioned of Julia's, that I threw towards the wall, twice?  She let us know what 'everyone' was thinking,  everyone had a say in that story....it was good to a point, but with the main guy character, it drove me nuts!  I didn't want to know what that guy was thinking!  He said one thing, and thought something else!   It made me want to kill the SOB!  And his wife went back to him, never having a clue...that's why I threw the D**n book!

 

(BTW, the sex scene in her book (with secondary characters) was on the edge of rape.  It didn't fit with her writing style, nor in her story.)   I hate out -of- the -blue sex, with no rime or reason.)  But, like we've all said, whatever works for you.  It obviously was a personal choice by the author.

 

For some reason, I don't want to hear the thoughts about sex, in a guys head.  I'd rather hear it come out of his mouth!  In his thoughts, alone,  it just sounds sleazy.

 

Also, Michelle, I like the way you write:  You're the true 'honesty-driven-devil's-advocate'.  :smileyhappy:

by Moderator becke_davis on 05-17-2009 03:45 PM
My daughter bought me an Anne Taintor magnet that says, "I like imaginary men the best!"
by Moderator dhaupt on 05-19-2009 09:22 AM
How true Becke, I mean the best sex I've ever had was between the pages of a book!!
by Veenstrabooks on 10-20-2010 06:36 AM

Currently i have three books that are listed as erotica located on the BN site, they have done well on amazon and smashwords, will be adding more once some of the bugs get worked out on the e-book formating here... however for now here are the books we have.

 

 

Knights of Came-a-lot: The Fall of Acheron

ISBN: 145371457X

http://search.barnesandnoble.com/Knights-of-Came-a-lot/Lord-Koga/e/2940011099809/?itm=1&USRI=lord+ko...

Genre: Erotic Fiction, Women’s Erotic Fiction, Erotic Fantasy

 Book Description:

 

In the land of Came-a-lot, Knights fight to the death over dominance, land, and sexual bragging rights.   In the mighty Kogarasumaru Alliance, Thanks to Lord Koga, peace has lasted for several years, but dark forces linger out on the rim of this world seeking to dethrone the beloved lord and ruin the Alliance forever. 

     Word has spread through the realm that the sinister leader of the Acheron Alliance is developing a new weapon able to take control of a man’s mind through the use of a new sexual technique.   Though this was only a rumor, Lord Koga dispatched two young and attractive females; members of the Elite Koga Sexual Infiltration Unit, and sent them in undercover, posing as new students of the local university to uncover the truth of this rumor.

      Now, as they have confirmed the potential threat that this weapon may have on the Realm, they have called upon their male counterparts to assist them in the sexual initiation right that they must pass in order to infiltrate the dark ranks of the Acheron Alliance, but alas, things are not as they appear…

 

 

 

Beyond my control: Book 1

 

 

http://search.barnesandnoble.com/books/e/2940011852886/?itm=2&USRI=lord+koga

 

Her fingers rising further up her body as she grabbed hold of her white shorts, pulling the slack to one side, she continued to stare intensely at me, my eyes gliding deeply up her shorts and to the fine, black, almost see-through lace of her panties wrapped tightly around her thighs, peaking out at me like an open invitation for the taking. Pushing her hands ever so slowly and gently into her hips, she rolled her eyes around the room, scrolling over everyone that sat around her; quickly making sure that they weren’t staring up at her and seeing the game of lustful desires that fooled around them like two sex crazed teenagers as they continued to play their useless game, never once becoming mindful of the raging lust quickly filling the room around them. Sighing almost quietly to herself, she tugged her fingers against her bottom shorts; tediously rolling them up and over waist only to drape the tips of her fingers against her sharply curved stomach, the soft overture outline of it rasping to the cool condition air.

 

Beyond my Control: Candy's Land Wife 2

 

http://search.barnesandnoble.com/books/e/2940011938900/?itm=3&USRI=lord+koga

 

Cheating on your husband with another man is one thing, however, Having sex with that man in the basment of your home on your husbands prized pool table while his sits in the living room watching the game just above you is dangerous....

 

For more books in this area you can look at our author website at: www.troyveenstra.com

 

by Linda_Krietz on 04-09-2011 09:41 PM

Hi all!

 

I recently stumbled on a great set of short stories by Chastity Lane described as "romantic erotica".

 

This adds another element to the discussion because as a short story, the time to develop the storyline is limited. At its heart, an erotic 'short story' must deliver primarily on the erotic front.

 

What I like about these Chastity Lane stories is they are completely focused on the erotica but have a base story that establishes a true romantic connection between the couple. I was so happy that these stories didn't have any sex with strangers or violence. That being said, the scenes are extremely steamy and erotic and are inextricably tied to a fun couple enjoying each other.

 

Check them out to compare and contrast.

 

-Linda

 

http://search.barnesandnoble.com/Island-Ecstasy/Chastity-Lane/e/2940012325273/?itm=4&USRI=chastity+l...

 

 

 

 

About Unabashedly Bookish: The BN Community Blog
Unabashedly Bookish features new articles every day from the Book Clubs staff, guest authors, and friends on hot topics in the world of books, language, writing, and publishing. From trends in the publishing business to updates on genre fiction fan communities, from fun lessons on grammar to reflections on literature in our personal lives, this blog is the best source for your daily dose of all things bookish.

Advertisement