I noticed that too, hopefully with an update they can make them sync up.
I haven't tried it. But it seems only logical they should be identical. Weird. Maybe it's another sync isue?
If I log into the B&N web site, there's a pulldown menu under "My Account" and one of the selections is "Wish list." Clicking on that takes me to my dead-tree wish list. At the upper left there's an option to "See My Other Wish Lists." Selecting "My eBook Wish List" takes me to, yes, my eBook wish list. But apparently this list is not the same as the "Wish List" within the Shop app on the NC. Is that right? Are these not tied together?
No, they aren't linked to each other, which is ridiculous. It isn't as if they didn't already hae the technology. The wish list on my NOOK Classic is linked to the one on my online account and always has been.
I won't be shopping from my NC for anything until this is fixed. I have no desire to manage two wish lists for one store. It's silliness.